Can Apprenticeships Fill the Skills Shortage in Engineering?

Karl Montgomery • October 21, 2024

Apprenticeships were once the backbone of the engineering sector. For many years, this tried-and-tested method of hands-on learning was the key route into skilled trades and technical professions. Yet, over the last 20 to 30 years, many companies moved away from apprenticeships, favouring university degrees and formal qualifications instead. As a result, the pipeline of skilled engineers has steadily declined, contributing to the skills shortage that the industry now faces.


Today, there is a growing recognition that traditional academic routes may not be the answer to closing the skills gap. Instead, there is a renewed interest in bringing back apprenticeships as a way to train a new generation of engineers who are equipped with both the theoretical knowledge and the practical experience necessary to thrive in a rapidly evolving industry.


But is reviving apprenticeships the best way to fill the skills shortage? Let’s explore how these programmes could once again become the foundation for engineering careers.


The Decline of Apprenticeships in Engineering

In the mid-20th century, apprenticeships were the most common path into engineering roles. Young people would join engineering firms, working alongside seasoned professionals while learning the skills of the trade. This hands-on experience, combined with formal education, ensured that by the end of their training, apprentices were fully qualified to step into skilled roles. The apprenticeship model not only produced highly capable engineers but also fostered long-term loyalty between apprentices and the companies that trained them.


However, over the last 20 or 30 years, many businesses began moving away from apprenticeships. The rise of higher education meant that more young people were encouraged to pursue university degrees, and companies increasingly sought candidates with academic qualifications over practical experience. As a result, the number of engineering apprenticeships dwindled, and many firms stopped offering these programmes altogether.


This shift had long-term consequences. While university graduates may enter the workforce with strong theoretical knowledge, they often lack the practical skills that are crucial in engineering roles. Employers have found that new hires need significant additional training before they can contribute effectively. This has contributed to the current skills shortage, as the demand for experienced, hands-on engineers continues to grow.


Bringing Apprenticeships Back: A Solution to the Skills Shortage

In light of these challenges, there is a growing recognition that apprenticeships need to be revived as a key training method for the engineering sector. Unlike traditional academic routes, apprenticeships offer a more balanced approach to learning, combining classroom instruction with real-world experience. Here’s why bringing back apprenticeships could be the answer to filling the skills gap in engineering:


  • Hands-On Experience is Key: Engineering is an inherently practical profession. Whether working on machinery, designing components, or managing projects, engineers need to be able to apply their knowledge in real-world scenarios. Apprenticeships provide this hands-on experience from day one, allowing trainees to develop the practical skills that are often lacking in university graduates.


  • Customised Training for Industry Needs: Apprenticeships can be tailored to the specific needs of an employer, ensuring that apprentices develop the precise skills that are in demand. This makes apprenticeships highly adaptable, allowing companies to train candidates in the latest technologies and practices that are specific to their industry. For example, an engineering firm focusing on renewable energy can train apprentices in the latest innovations in that field, ensuring a future-ready workforce.


  • Bridging the Generational Gap: With a significant portion of the engineering workforce nearing retirement, there is an urgent need to transfer knowledge to the next generation. Apprenticeships allow experienced engineers to pass on their expertise to apprentices, ensuring that valuable knowledge isn’t lost when older workers retire. This approach helps to create continuity within organisations and ensures that critical skills are preserved.


  • Cost-Effective for Employers and Trainees: Apprenticeships are often more cost-effective than hiring university graduates who may require additional training. Employers can train apprentices on the job, moulding them into highly capable employees who are familiar with the company's systems, culture, and processes. For apprentices, the "earn while you learn" model makes this a more financially accessible route into engineering, avoiding the high costs associated with university education.

While university degrees offer a deep understanding of engineering principles, they don’t always prepare graduates for the practical realities of the job. Theoretical knowledge is essential, but without hands-on experience, many graduates struggle to transition into the workforce smoothly. This disconnect has left companies needing to invest heavily in additional training for new hires, which prolongs the time it takes for them to become productive.


Moreover, the rise of digital technologies and automation in the engineering sector means that the skills required are constantly evolving. Apprenticeships offer the flexibility to adjust training programmes quickly, ensuring that apprentices are learning the most up-to-date skills. University courses, on the other hand, can be slower to adapt to changes in the industry, making it harder for graduates to stay current with industry needs.


The Return of Apprenticeships: Success Stories

Several companies are already seeing the benefits of bringing back apprenticeship programmes. For example, Jaguar Land Rover has reinvested in apprenticeships as a way to fill its skills gap in manufacturing and engineering. The company offers apprenticeships that combine academic learning with practical experience in areas such as electrical engineering, manufacturing, and product development.


Similarly, Balfour Beatty, a leading infrastructure company, has launched apprenticeship programmes to address the skills shortage in civil and mechanical engineering. These apprenticeships allow young people to gain experience on major construction projects, learning the essential skills needed to succeed in the industry.


These companies recognise that apprenticeships are not just a way to fill immediate vacancies—they are a long-term investment in the future of their workforce. By training apprentices, these businesses are ensuring that they have a steady pipeline of skilled engineers who are familiar with their processes and ready to take on more responsibility as they progress in their careers.


Practical Tips for Creating an Effective Apprenticeship Programme

1. Identify Specific Skill Gaps in Your Organisation


Before launching an apprenticeship programme, it’s important to conduct a thorough skills audit. Where are your company’s biggest gaps? Are you lacking expertise in specific areas like mechanical systems, electrical engineering, or data-driven manufacturing processes? This assessment will help you design a programme that addresses your company’s unique needs and ensure that apprentices are trained in the areas most critical to your business.


For example, if your company is implementing new automation technologies, your apprenticeship programme should focus on developing skills related to robotics, machine learning, and system integration. Tailoring the programme to meet these specific requirements will ensure that apprentices are well-equipped to tackle your company's immediate and future challenges.


2. Collaborate with Educational Institutions


A successful apprenticeship programme often involves collaboration with local colleges or vocational schools. Educational institutions can provide the necessary classroom-based learning that complements on-the-job training. By partnering with these organisations, you ensure that apprentices receive a well-rounded education that blends theory with practice.


Establish clear communication with educational partners to develop a curriculum that aligns with your company's goals. Consider creating a bespoke course that integrates your specific technologies, tools, and methodologies into the broader academic content.


3. Mentorship is Key to Apprenticeship Success


One of the greatest strengths of apprenticeships is the opportunity for new talent to learn directly from experienced professionals. To maximise this benefit, it’s crucial to have a formal mentorship structure in place. Assign skilled engineers or technicians as mentors to guide apprentices through the process, offering practical insights and advice that can’t be found in textbooks.


Mentorship also plays a key role in employee engagement and retention. By fostering strong mentor-apprentice relationships, companies create a supportive learning environment that encourages apprentices to stay and grow within the organisation. Be sure to offer mentors training on how to effectively coach and develop apprentices.


4. Develop a Clear Progression Pathway


Apprenticeships are about long-term investment, so it's essential to create a clear career progression for your apprentices. Outline the skills, knowledge, and milestones that apprentices are expected to achieve at each stage of the programme. This not only gives apprentices a sense of direction and purpose but also allows you to track their progress.


Consider developing a multi-level apprenticeship programme, with distinct pathways for different engineering specialisations. For instance, an electrical engineering apprentice might progress through levels of increasing responsibility, from basic circuit design to managing electrical installations on complex projects. This structure can serve as both a motivational tool for apprentices and a strategic framework for your company’s talent development.


5. Incorporate Digital Skills and Emerging Technologies


The engineering sector is becoming increasingly reliant on digital tools and technologies, from 3D printing and CAD software to artificial intelligence and the Internet of Things (IoT). It’s important that your apprenticeship programme incorporates training in these emerging areas to prepare apprentices for the future of engineering.


Ensure that apprentices are exposed to the latest technologies and taught how to work with digital tools that will be critical to their roles. This could involve partnerships with technology providers to ensure access to cutting-edge equipment, or investing in specialised training that complements your in-house expertise.


6. Offer Competitive Compensation and Benefits


While apprentices are often new to the workforce, it’s important to offer competitive compensation that reflects the value they bring to your organisation. A fair wage not only helps to attract talented candidates but also reinforces the idea that apprenticeships are a respected, viable alternative to traditional academic routes.


Additionally, consider offering benefits such as training allowances, travel expenses, and opportunities for further education. Showing that you’re committed to the professional development of apprentices will make your programme more attractive and competitive.


7. Evaluate and Adapt the Programme Regularly


Like any business initiative, your apprenticeship programme should be regularly evaluated and adjusted as needed. Gather feedback from apprentices, mentors, and other stakeholders to understand what’s working and what areas need improvement. Track the progress of apprentices and measure key outcomes such as retention rates, skill development, and eventual job placement.


Make sure to adapt the programme to reflect changing industry trends and emerging skill requirements. For example, as automation continues to grow, your programme might need to expand its focus on robotics and artificial intelligence. Keeping the programme dynamic and responsive to change will ensure it remains relevant and effective.

As the engineering sector faces an ever-widening skills gap, apprenticeships are emerging as a vital solution to train the next generation of engineers. By developing a well-structured, industry-focused apprenticeship programme, companies can cultivate homegrown talent, tailor skills to meet their specific needs, and ensure a steady pipeline of skilled professionals.


For businesses looking to remain competitive in a rapidly evolving landscape, now is the time to reinvest in apprenticeships as a strategic tool for workforce development.

By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
The success of any hire isn’t just about technical skills or years of experience—it’s about finding the right person who can thrive in the role, solve problems effectively, and adapt to challenges. Yet, many traditional interview questions fail to assess these qualities. Instead of asking predictable questions like "What are your strengths and weaknesses?", hiring managers should focus on behavioural and situational interview techniques that uncover a candidate’s true potential.
By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
Warehousing has long been the unsung hero of the UK’s supply chain. From enabling the e-commerce boom to supporting the manufacturing sector, warehouses play a crucial role in keeping goods moving efficiently. Yet, despite its undeniable importance, the sector remains overlooked by policymakers—a situation that could have serious repercussions for the UK economy. In this blog, we’ll explore the vital role of warehousing, the challenges it faces, and what industry leaders can do to secure its future.
By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
Hiring the right candidate can be challenging, especially when faced with CVs that look impressive but don’t reflect true competency. Some candidates master the art of presenting themselves well on paper without the experience or skills to succeed in the role. Here’s a deep dive into common CV red flags and practical steps to assess candidates effectively.
By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
The food manufacturing industry is facing a significant challenge: a growing skills shortage that's impacting productivity and operational efficiency. As demand for food production rises, companies must adopt innovative strategies to attract, retain, and develop skilled talent. Here's a comprehensive guide to addressing this workforce crisis.
By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
Navigating the job market can feel overwhelming, but with a structured approach, you can significantly increase your chances of landing your ideal role. This guide breaks down the key steps to take, from perfecting your CV to acing your interview.
By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
The UK engineering industry is at a crossroads. With an ever-growing skills shortage, firms are struggling to find the talent they need to maintain operations, innovate, and grow. However, within this challenge lies an opportunity: companies that rethink their recruitment strategies can transform this crisis into a competitive advantage. Here’s how engineering firms can turn the skills shortage into a strength through strategic hiring practices. 1. Build a Standout Employer Brand In a market where skilled engineers are in high demand, your reputation as an employer matters more than ever. A strong employer brand not only helps attract talent but also improves retention. Here’s what to focus on: Showcase Your Culture: Use your website, social media, and job ads to highlight your company’s values, projects, and workplace environment. Share Employee Success Stories: Potential hires want to see themselves succeeding in your business. Promote testimonials and case studies from current team members. Be Transparent About Growth Opportunities: Skilled professionals seek roles that offer development and career progression. Make these opportunities clear from the outset. 2. Adopt a Strategic Workforce Planning Approach Long-term success requires a proactive approach to workforce development. Engineering firms must anticipate future skills needs and implement strategies to address them: Skills Gap Analysis: Identify the skills you’ll need in the coming years and compare them against your current capabilities. Collaborate with Educational Institutions: Partner with universities, colleges, and apprenticeship programs to build a talent pipeline. Invest in Upskilling: Offer training and development opportunities to existing staff, ensuring they stay ahead of industry changes. 3. Get Creative with Recruitment Strategies Traditional recruitment methods alone won’t solve the skills shortage. Engineering firms need to think outside the box: Target Passive Candidates: Many of the best candidates aren’t actively job hunting. Use networking events, social media, and headhunting tactics to engage this group. Offer Flexible Work Options: Flexibility is increasingly important to today’s workforce. Remote working, flexible hours, and project-based contracts can attract professionals who might otherwise overlook your roles. Utilise Specialist Recruitment Partners: Generalist recruiters may struggle to find niche engineering talent. Partnering with a recruiter who understands the industry can yield better results. 4. Focus on Candidate Experience In a competitive market, candidate experience can be the deciding factor in securing top talent. From application to onboarding, ensure your process is smooth, engaging, and respectful: Simplify the Application Process: Avoid lengthy, cumbersome forms. Communicate Regularly: Keep candidates informed about their application status. Provide Constructive Feedback: Even unsuccessful applicants should leave with a positive impression of your business.
By Karl Montgomery February 3, 2025
Attracting and nurturing early career talent is more than just filling entry-level roles—it's about developing the workforce of the future. A well-planned early careers recruitment strategy not only helps businesses secure top young talent but also strengthens long-term workforce planning, diversity, and innovation.
By Karl Montgomery February 3, 2025
Picture this: two candidates apply for the same job. One has a degree from a top university but little hands-on experience. The other has no formal qualifications but has spent years honing the exact skills needed for the role. Who should get the job? If your hiring process is stuck in the past, you might overlook the second candidate entirely. Skills-based hiring is changing that—and it’s transforming the way companies find the best talent.
By Karl Montgomery February 3, 2025
In an increasingly competitive job market, personal branding has become a crucial element in securing the right opportunities. Employers are not just looking at CVs anymore; they’re checking LinkedIn, reviewing social media, and assessing how candidates present themselves online. Your personal brand can make or break your job search.
By Karl Montgomery January 28, 2025
The job market is evolving, and one of the most striking trends emerging is the stark contrast in job application behaviour between younger and older workers. Recent data reveals that Gen Z applicants are applying for twice as many jobs as their older counterparts. But what is driving this trend, and what does it mean for employers and recruiters?
Show More
Share by: