Interview Questions That Predict Success: What Hiring Managers Should Really Be Asking

Karl Montgomery • February 18, 2025

The success of any hire isn’t just about technical skills or years of experience—it’s about finding the right person who can thrive in the role, solve problems effectively, and adapt to challenges. Yet, many traditional interview questions fail to assess these qualities.

 

Instead of asking predictable questions like "What are your strengths and weaknesses?", hiring managers should focus on behavioural and situational interview techniques that uncover a candidate’s true potential.


Why Traditional Interview Questions Fall Short

Many common interview questions are overly broad, invite rehearsed responses, or don’t provide insights into how a candidate will actually perform on the job.

 

Problems with Generic Questions:

 

  • Encourage rehearsed answers – Candidates often anticipate and practice responses that sound good rather than reflect reality.
  • Lack predictive validity – They fail to reveal a candidate’s true decision-making process, problem-solving ability, or adaptability.
  • Don’t assess cultural fit – Workplace success is about more than technical skills; attitude, motivation, and teamwork play crucial roles.



Behavioural Questions That Reveal Problem-Solving Ability

Behavioural interview questions focus on how a candidate handled situations in the past, which can indicate how they will perform in the future.

 

Key Questions to Ask:

 

1. Tell me about a time you faced an unexpected problem at work. How did you handle it?

  • What to look for: How the candidate identifies issues, takes initiative, and overcomes obstacles.


2. Describe a situation where you had to quickly learn something new to complete a task. How did you approach it?

  • What to look for: Adaptability and willingness to take on challenges.


3. Can you give an example of a time when you had to persuade others to see things your way?

  • What to look for: Communication skills, influencing abilities, and emotional intelligence.


Situational Questions to Test Adaptability and Decision-Making

Situational questions present hypothetical challenges and gauge how a candidate would handle them.

 

Key Questions to Ask:

 

1. If you were assigned a project with a tight deadline and incomplete instructions, how would you proceed?

  • What to look for: Problem-solving, resourcefulness, and prioritisation skills.

2. Imagine you’re leading a team, and two team members strongly disagree on an approach. How would you handle the situation?

  • What to look for: Conflict resolution and leadership abilities.

3. Your manager asks you to take on a responsibility outside of your job description. How would you respond?

  • What to look for: Growth mindset, willingness to learn, and team-oriented attitude.


Cultural Fit Questions to Ensure Long-Term Success

Hiring the right talent isn’t just about skills—it’s about finding candidates who align with the company’s values and work culture.

 

Key Questions to Ask:

 

1. What type of work environment allows you to do your best work?

  • What to look for: Whether their preferred environment matches the company’s culture.

2. Describe a time you worked in a team that wasn’t functioning well. How did you handle it?

  • What to look for: Conflict management, teamwork, and self-awareness.

3. How do you like to receive feedback? Can you give an example of a time when feedback helped you improve?

  • What to look for: Openness to growth and ability to accept constructive criticism.


The Power of Structured Interviewing

A structured interview process—where all candidates are asked the same carefully designed questions—leads to more objective hiring decisions and better predictive accuracy.

 

Steps to Implement a Structured Interview Approach:

 

1. Define Key Competencies – Identify the must-have skills, qualities, and values for the role.

2. Develop a Standardised Question Set – Ensure all candidates answer the same behavioural, situational, and cultural fit questions.

3. Use a Rating System – Score responses consistently to minimise bias.

4. Train Hiring Managers – Equip interviewers with the right skills to assess candidates effectively.


Conclusion: Hiring Smarter, Not Harder

A structured interview process—where all candidates are asked the same carefully designed questions—leads to more objective hiring decisions and better predictive accuracy.

 

Steps to Implement a Structured Interview Approach:

 

1. Define Key Competencies – Identify the must-have skills, qualities, and values for the role.

2. Develop a Standardised Question Set – Ensure all candidates answer the same behavioural, situational, and cultural fit questions.

3. Use a Rating System – Score responses consistently to minimise bias.

4. Train Hiring Managers – Equip interviewers with the right skills to assess candidates effectively.

By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
Warehousing has long been the unsung hero of the UK’s supply chain. From enabling the e-commerce boom to supporting the manufacturing sector, warehouses play a crucial role in keeping goods moving efficiently. Yet, despite its undeniable importance, the sector remains overlooked by policymakers—a situation that could have serious repercussions for the UK economy. In this blog, we’ll explore the vital role of warehousing, the challenges it faces, and what industry leaders can do to secure its future.
By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
Hiring the right candidate can be challenging, especially when faced with CVs that look impressive but don’t reflect true competency. Some candidates master the art of presenting themselves well on paper without the experience or skills to succeed in the role. Here’s a deep dive into common CV red flags and practical steps to assess candidates effectively.
By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
The food manufacturing industry is facing a significant challenge: a growing skills shortage that's impacting productivity and operational efficiency. As demand for food production rises, companies must adopt innovative strategies to attract, retain, and develop skilled talent. Here's a comprehensive guide to addressing this workforce crisis.
By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
Navigating the job market can feel overwhelming, but with a structured approach, you can significantly increase your chances of landing your ideal role. This guide breaks down the key steps to take, from perfecting your CV to acing your interview.
By Karl Montgomery February 18, 2025
The UK engineering industry is at a crossroads. With an ever-growing skills shortage, firms are struggling to find the talent they need to maintain operations, innovate, and grow. However, within this challenge lies an opportunity: companies that rethink their recruitment strategies can transform this crisis into a competitive advantage. Here’s how engineering firms can turn the skills shortage into a strength through strategic hiring practices. 1. Build a Standout Employer Brand In a market where skilled engineers are in high demand, your reputation as an employer matters more than ever. A strong employer brand not only helps attract talent but also improves retention. Here’s what to focus on: Showcase Your Culture: Use your website, social media, and job ads to highlight your company’s values, projects, and workplace environment. Share Employee Success Stories: Potential hires want to see themselves succeeding in your business. Promote testimonials and case studies from current team members. Be Transparent About Growth Opportunities: Skilled professionals seek roles that offer development and career progression. Make these opportunities clear from the outset. 2. Adopt a Strategic Workforce Planning Approach Long-term success requires a proactive approach to workforce development. Engineering firms must anticipate future skills needs and implement strategies to address them: Skills Gap Analysis: Identify the skills you’ll need in the coming years and compare them against your current capabilities. Collaborate with Educational Institutions: Partner with universities, colleges, and apprenticeship programs to build a talent pipeline. Invest in Upskilling: Offer training and development opportunities to existing staff, ensuring they stay ahead of industry changes. 3. Get Creative with Recruitment Strategies Traditional recruitment methods alone won’t solve the skills shortage. Engineering firms need to think outside the box: Target Passive Candidates: Many of the best candidates aren’t actively job hunting. Use networking events, social media, and headhunting tactics to engage this group. Offer Flexible Work Options: Flexibility is increasingly important to today’s workforce. Remote working, flexible hours, and project-based contracts can attract professionals who might otherwise overlook your roles. Utilise Specialist Recruitment Partners: Generalist recruiters may struggle to find niche engineering talent. Partnering with a recruiter who understands the industry can yield better results. 4. Focus on Candidate Experience In a competitive market, candidate experience can be the deciding factor in securing top talent. From application to onboarding, ensure your process is smooth, engaging, and respectful: Simplify the Application Process: Avoid lengthy, cumbersome forms. Communicate Regularly: Keep candidates informed about their application status. Provide Constructive Feedback: Even unsuccessful applicants should leave with a positive impression of your business.
By Karl Montgomery February 3, 2025
Attracting and nurturing early career talent is more than just filling entry-level roles—it's about developing the workforce of the future. A well-planned early careers recruitment strategy not only helps businesses secure top young talent but also strengthens long-term workforce planning, diversity, and innovation.
By Karl Montgomery February 3, 2025
Picture this: two candidates apply for the same job. One has a degree from a top university but little hands-on experience. The other has no formal qualifications but has spent years honing the exact skills needed for the role. Who should get the job? If your hiring process is stuck in the past, you might overlook the second candidate entirely. Skills-based hiring is changing that—and it’s transforming the way companies find the best talent.
By Karl Montgomery February 3, 2025
In an increasingly competitive job market, personal branding has become a crucial element in securing the right opportunities. Employers are not just looking at CVs anymore; they’re checking LinkedIn, reviewing social media, and assessing how candidates present themselves online. Your personal brand can make or break your job search.
By Karl Montgomery January 28, 2025
The job market is evolving, and one of the most striking trends emerging is the stark contrast in job application behaviour between younger and older workers. Recent data reveals that Gen Z applicants are applying for twice as many jobs as their older counterparts. But what is driving this trend, and what does it mean for employers and recruiters?
By Karl Montgomery January 28, 2025
In today’s competitive hiring landscape, understanding how candidates search for jobs has never been more important. With Artificial Intelligence (AI) transforming everything from search algorithms to personalised recommendations, employers have an unprecedented opportunity to optimise their job advertising strategies. By leveraging insights into AI-driven job searching, businesses can maximise their advertising budgets and attract higher-quality candidates. Here, we delve into how AI impacts job searches and what employers can do to stay ahead of the curve.
Show More
Share by: